Customer Reviews

I have had my car and house insurance with Mathews since they started up. I have had one claim from storm damage and I was so surprised how easy it was to file a claim. They sent their adjuster out right away and I got my contractor involved and away they went. I have know Karen and Randy and their sibling for a long time. Good honest people in business.

I have Been with Erie Insurance over 20 years they have always given me the best Service.

I have been with Mathews Insurance for over 20 years. I wish I would’ve connected with them 50 years ago. Always very helpful and explains my covered property to me in full detail and in my language . Thank you Karen for having my back. Paul Keebler

Mathews insurance is very prompt on their responses, friendly and very helpful. They compare insurance providers to ensure we are paying the best rates