Your Friends in Insurance

Our Insurance Products

Home Insurance

Auto Insurance

Medicare

Life Insurance

Mathews Insurance Agency Inc. specializes in Auto, Home, Life Insurance, Medicare Advantage, and Medicare Supplement Insurance Plans (Medigap).

Insuring Indiana, Arizona, Ohio, & Florida

At Mathews Insurance Agency Inc., our priority is helping our customers find the best coverage in order to protect what matters most in life. As an Independent agency, we work with a wide variety of top carriers to help you find the best coverage to suit your exact situation.

No matter your insurance needs, we can help you find the perfect policy to give you peace of mind without breaking the bank. Contact us for a quote today!

 5/5

5 stars!

Melody K.

 5/5

friendly service and good pricing

Richard H.

 5/5

Very happy!

Laurie B.

 5/5

They've done a good job keeping my insurance rates as low as possible.

Jeffrey D Fuller.

 5/5

Top notch coverage, customer service, and claims are handled quick

Jason M.

 5/5

Very happy with the service

Dottie T.

Recent News & Updates

Budget vs. Benefits: Choosing the Right Health Insurance Plan

April 25, 2024

Navigating the world of health insurance can be complex, especially when balancing budget constraints with the need for comprehensive coverage. When choosing a health insurance…

Don’t Let These 7 Reasons Hold You Back from Buying Life Insurance

April 24, 2024

Are you like the majority of Americans who don’t have life insurance1, but say that they know they need it? With the price of everything…

young woman holding a small plant in her hands

Leveraging Life Insurance to Make a Difference

April 22, 2024

Earth Day serves as a poignant reminder of the importance of preserving our planet for future generations. As individuals committed to protecting the environment, many…