Skip to ContentSkip to Footer

Karen Cogdell

General Manager

I have been employed with Mathews Insurance since 1999 when the owner, my brother, recruited me.  I currently serve as General Manager over our three Indiana offices, Fairmount, Kokomo, and Fort Wayne. My co-workers make that job title easy.  I have many clients over the years that I am lucky to also call friends. We share ups and downs together that have made this a great journey that I consider a privilege.  

If I can provide great service, save you money, and place you with a fabulous company, it is a win for me. My goal is and always has been to share insurance education whenever possible.  

Outside of these office walls, I am a mother of two grown daughters, six grandchildren, and two mastiffs (the beasts). I am an active member of Westview Wesleyan Church. I like to read and watch movies in between grandchildren’s ball games.  

I would love to help you with your insurance needs and share life along the way. Please feel free to call and ask for me.

Karen Cogdell Headshot
Specializing In ERIE Insurance
Get an Auto Quote
Get an Auto Quote
Pay Your Bill
Pay Your Bill
Life Insurance Calculator
Life Insurance Calculator
Access Online Account
Access Online Account
Get A Quote

* indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Customer Reviews
Rated 5 out of 5

Thanks for all the help!

SS
sharron s
Rated 5 out of 5

very helpful

JV
jr v
Rated 5 out of 5

friendly service and good pricing

RH
richard h
Rated 4 out of 5

(Translated by Google) Alright (Original) Esta bien

AZ
Ade Z
Rated 4 out of 5

This is a good place to get house and car insurance . that will help you ?

David Grear
David G